F1 2009

madmax17
madmax17
Većinski vlasnik Foruma
Pristupio: 28.04.2007.
Poruka: 28.416
22. rujna 2009. u 00:10
Analysis: How Renault case came to light


When news first broke at the Belgian Grand Prix that the FIA was conducting an investigation into the events at the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix, the initial suspicion was that this was a case of a disgruntled former employee going out for revenge.

The matter then disappeared below the radar for several days, with neither Renault nor the Piquets making any further comment about it prior to the FIA World Motor Sport Council hearing in Paris on September 21.

Yet that all changed in the build-up to the Italian Grand Prix when, on the Wednesday night before the race, AUTOSPORT revealed the first details about the case - and how it revolved around a pre-race meeting between Nelson Piquet Jr., Pat Symonds and Flavio Briatore.

That story resulted in the Renault controversy building up a huge news momentum, with leaked documents, claims and counterclaims from Renault, plus numerous press briefings at Monza dominating the weekend before it was capped off with the departure of Briatore and Symonds on Tuesday this week.

With the events having moved on so quickly, AUTOSPORT has pulled together all we know so far to shed some light on the affair.

HOW DID THE AFFAIR COME TO LIGHT?

By the Hungarian Grand Prix in August, Nelson Piquet Jr. knew that his contractual situation at the team was precarious. In fact, Briatore had informed the Brazilian driver shortly after the German GP that he wanted to terminate his race contract.

Piquet's father was locked in discussions with Briatore about a way forward - with his son having failed to score the points needed to avert Renault's ability to terminate his contract.

The Piquets had headed off dismissal after the German GP because the team had not totally fulfilled contract criteria that demanded an equal car at all events - with Alonso having got some latest developments at the Nurburgring.

Rather than appear depressed about the situation, however, Piquet said he was staying out of matters - leaving it all for his father.

"There was a bit of a mess at the last race, I knew there was a big chance for me to be here - there was just conflict, and contracts, and a conflict of egos between a few people. But, it ended up with everything working well," he said ahead of the Hungarian Grand Prix.

Nelson Piquet Sr and Junior"The problem is that these days a contract in F1 doesn't mean much, and we have seen several cases already of drivers and teams breaking contracts, and it just stays that way. So, the only thing I can do is drive, do my best and leave my father to do his job and see what he can do.

"I always have to try and do my best, and now that I have a better chance now that I have the same car, and not only that - but it also looks like the car is quite quick. Then it is an easier chance to show something."

Piquet's Hungarian GP was a disappointment, however. He qualified 12th, with Alonso on pole position, and came home a lowly 14th. That day, however, the wheels for the Singapore controversy were firmly set in motion. Piquet Sr. contacted FIA president Max Mosley telling him that his son wanted to make a statement concerning an incident at the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix.

Arrangements were duly made, and Piquet Jr. attended a meeting in Paris on the Thursday after the Hungarian Grand Prix. It was there he revealed in sworn testimony to Alan Donnelly, the chairman of the stewards, plus an FIA external adviser from investigations agency Quest, his version of events at Singapore.

WHAT DID PIQUET CLAIM?

Once at the FIA, Piquet made it clear that his crash at the Singapore Grand Prix had been caused deliberately as the result of a plan put to him by Symonds and Briatore.

His statement said: "During the Formula One Grand Prix of Singapore, held on 28 September 2008 and counting towards the 2008 FIA Formula One World Championship, I was asked by Mr. Flavio Briatore, who is both my manager and the Team Principal of the ING Renault F1 Team, and by Mr. Pat Symonds, the Technical Director of the Renault F1 Team, to deliberately crash my car in order to positively influence the performance of the ING Renault F1 Team at the event in question. I agreed to this proposal and caused my car to hit a wall and crash during lap thirteen/fourteen of the race.

"The proposal to deliberately cause an accident was made to me shortly before the race took place, when I was summoned by Mr. Briatore and Mr. Symonds in Mr. Briatore's office. Mr. Symonds, in the presence of Mr. Briatore, asked me if I would be willing to sacrifice my race for the team by "causing a safety car".

"Every F1 race driver knows that the safety car is deployed on a track when there is an accident which leads to the track being blocked either by debris or a stationary car, and where it is difficult to recover a damaged car, as was the case here." Piquet said that he agreed to deliberately crash his car because he was 'in a very fragile and emotional state of mind' following difficult contract talks with Briatore.

Nelson Piquet Jr at the 2008 Singapore GPHe added: "After the meeting with Mr. Symonds and Mr. Briatore, Mr. Symonds took me aside to a quiet corner and, using a map, pointed me to the exact corner of the track where I should crash.

"This corner was selected because the specific location of the track did not have any cranes that would allow a damaged car to be swiftly lifted off the track, nor did it have any side entrances to the track, which would allow a Safety Marshall [sic] to quickly move the damaged car away from the track. Therefore, it was felt that a crash in this specific position would be nearly certain to cause an obstruction on the track which would thus necessitate the deployment of a safety car in order to allow the track to be cleared and to ensure the safe continuation of the race.

"Mr. Symonds also told me which exact lap to cause the incident upon, so that a strategy could be deployed for my team-mate Mr. Fernando Alonso to refuel at the pit shortly before the deployment of the safety car, which he indeed did during lap twelve.

"The key to this strategy resided in the fact that the near-knowledge that the safety car would be deployed in lap thirteen/fourteen allowed the Team to start Mr. Alonso's car with an aggressive fuel strategy using a light car containing enough fuel to arrive at lap twelve, but not much more. This would allow Mr. Alonso to overtake as many (heavier) cars as possible, knowing that those cars would have difficulty catching up with him later in the race due to the later deployment of the safety car. This strategy was successful and Mr. Alonso won the 2008 Formula One Grand Prix of Singapore.

"I intentionally caused the crash by letting go of control of the car just before the relevant corner. In order to make sure I would cause the incident during the correct lap, I asked my team several times via the radio to confirm the lap number, which I would not normally do. I was not injured during the accident, nor was anyone else." Piquet said that the matter was never discussed again after the race, and claimed that Briatore had discreetly said 'thank you' that Sunday night.

He also said that he told his family friend and advisor Felipe Vargas about the incident - and Mr. Vargas told Piquet Sr.

"After the race several journalists asked questions about the accident and asked me whether I had caused it on purpose, because they felt it was 'suspicious'," added Piquet.

"In my own team, the engineer of my car questioned the nature of the incident because he found it unusual, and I replied that I had lost control of the car. I believe that a clever engineer would notice from the car's telemetry that I caused the incident on purpose as I continued accelerating, whereas a 'normal' reaction would be to brake as soon as possible."

Piquet was summoned again by the FIA to provide a secondary statement with more details of the incident, to provide clearer details of the timing of events in the build-up to the grand prix - as well as confirm his view on telemetry data that had been provided by the FIA Technical Department.

He clarified that the meeting where the crash plan was discussed took place between 4pm and 5pm on race day - and that it did not last very long.

"In the course of the meeting, Briatore said very little," claimed Piquet. "As the meeting drew to a close, Mr. Symonds told me that I should not speak about the plan with anyone else and said that he would give me further instructions shortly. I believe the meeting in Mr Briatore's office lasted no more than ten minutes."

After claiming that Symonds later told him where to crash on the track, Piquet provided further evidence about how he deliberately caused the accident.

"After ensuring I was on the designated lap of the race, I deliberately lost control of my car on the exit to turn 17. I did this by pressing hard and early on the throttle.

Nelson Piquet, Renault, Singapore 2008"As I felt the back end of the car drifting out, I continued to press hard on the throttle, in the knowledge that this would lead to my car making heavy contact with the concrete wall on the far side of the track and thereby cause a crash necessitating the deployment of the safety car."

He added: "Once the back end of the car had begun to drift out, the only way of recovering control of the car and avoiding a contact with the concrete wall would have been to back off on the throttle.

"However, I did not back off the throttle to any material extent. Rather, I pressed hard on the throttle beyond the moment at which the back end started to drift out and, indeed, right up to and beyond the point of impact with the concrete wall."

Kakav podmukao plan nemreš belivit.

Alonso nije ništa znao naravno on si misli "uf koja sreća, taman sam si napunio auto gorivom krug prije nego što se moj timski kolega zaletio u zid zbog čega je safety car izašao na stazu"

[uredio madmax17 - 22. rujna 2009. u 00:11]
"Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast!" 🎸⚽🏀🎨
Obrisan korisnik
Obrisan korisnik
Pristupio: 20.04.2005.
Poruka: 7.318
28. rujna 2009. u 22:35
Alonso donosi previše love da bi išta 'znao'. Koga briga za njega, koji je moralna nakaza jer je pokazao da ne trpi konkurenciju u momcadi. Neće on ferrari stavit na noge, to je mogao samo tata.
dr.Damir
dr.Damir
Većinski vlasnik Foruma
Pristupio: 12.06.2006.
Poruka: 20.131
18. listopada 2009. u 18:16
Kakav početak utrke, ovo bi moglo bit sjajno.
Nadam se da će se Barrichello dokopat naslova.
sve prolazi sve se mijenja, idu dani idu godine, samo Zrinjski ostaje ponos moje Hercegovine
Deadpool
Deadpool
Potencijal za velika djela
Pristupio: 09.10.2009.
Poruka: 4.999
18. listopada 2009. u 19:40
I tako smo dobili vjerovatno najgoreg svjetskog prvaka ikad. woo hoo
Man, I love duct tape. I love how it tapes, I love the sound it makes. I love saying it. Duct tape. Duct tape. Duct tape...Duct tape...
MaidenMadness
MaidenMadness
Mali dioničar
Pristupio: 29.05.2007.
Poruka: 9.339
18. listopada 2009. u 20:05
ajde koliko su bili vikali o tom gumbicu kada je tek bio dosao u f1 napokon neka je i on nesto napravio.
[uredio MaidenMadness - 18. listopada 2009. u 20:05]
The world is full of Kings and QueensWho blind your eyes and steal your dreams
Obrisan korisnik
Obrisan korisnik
Pristupio: 22.07.2009.
Poruka: 1.979
19. listopada 2009. u 17:07
misilm da najvecu pocast treba dati ross brown.. covjek je stvarno cudo u tom sportu..
Deadpool
Deadpool
Potencijal za velika djela
Pristupio: 09.10.2009.
Poruka: 4.999
19. listopada 2009. u 18:57
Button je otkad su svi ugradili dvostruke difuzore uspio osvojit maestralih 2.6 bodova prosječno po utrci. Pravi prvak nema šta.
Man, I love duct tape. I love how it tapes, I love the sound it makes. I love saying it. Duct tape. Duct tape. Duct tape...Duct tape...
Obrisan korisnik
Obrisan korisnik
Pristupio: 22.09.2009.
Poruka: 1.013
20. listopada 2009. u 14:52
Button je smeće, jedan je Fernandinho....Hehe. Iduća godina će biti pod imenom jednog čovjeka... Fernando Alonso...
madmax17
madmax17
Većinski vlasnik Foruma
Pristupio: 28.04.2007.
Poruka: 28.416
20. listopada 2009. u 15:06
Bolid je bitniji od vozača nije ovo trka na 110 sa preponama.
"Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast!" 🎸⚽🏀🎨
Obrisan korisnik
Obrisan korisnik
Pristupio: 20.02.2006.
Poruka: 35.530
20. listopada 2009. u 18:18
zato mi to i nije bas sport. dodje ko neka zasebna kategorija...
  • Najnovije
  • Najčitanije