Pep’s handbook to manage a healthy midfield

With the improving fitness of Bastian Schweinsteiger and Javi Martinez, Bayern will soon be faced with the inevitable problem of having so many world-class midfielders that someone will have to ride the bench, unless Pep Guardiola decides that defenders and goalkeepers don’t fit into his plans. (If that’s the case, Manuel Neuer would make the perfect defensive midfielder.) But who will play, and how will Pep’s midfield shape up?
The formation
So far, Bayern has used a 4-1-4-1 formation with the occasional dalliance with a 4-2-3-1 depending on who is fit and what team they are playing. The main problem with predicting how Bayern’s midfield will shape up under Guardiola is that because of the injuries to key players like Schweinsteiger, Martinez, and for a time Thiago (who at the time was not a key player) it’s difficult to say exactly what Guardiola wants to do when he has everyone at his disposal.
Let’s assume that Guardiola will start most games with the 4-1-4-1 because of its flexibility on the pitch. The 4-1-4-1 has many drawbacks, but one thing it certainly brings to the table is that it can easily shift into a 4-2-3-1 or a 4-3-3 if it has to with just a simple shift of the players positions or a substitution if need be. The formation includes two wingers, two central midfielders, and a defensive anchor. While the single pivot does not provide as much protection as the double pivot under Heynckes, but with the right midfielders on the pitch it can provide a similar effect.
The players
Saying Bayern doesn’t have a shortage of midfielders is probably the Bundesliga understatement of the year. Franck Ribéry, Arjen Robben, Bastian Schweinsteiger, Thomas Müller, Toni Kroos, Javi Martinez, Xherdan Shaqiri, and recently Philipp Lahm of all players are all viable starters for the various midfield positions.
For the wings, Franck Ribéry and Arjen Robben are almost on lock-down to start barring injury. (Get well soon, Franck’s buttock.) Arjen Robben has also started consistently when fit, and it’s hard to argue with the Dutchman’s inclusion when he’s already notched seven and three assists already this season. Both Ribéry and Robben are highly technical players who can dribble, cross, create chances, and score, and contribute almost exactly what Guardiola looks for in a winger. We can be fairly certain that there won’t be a lot of important games that they miss.
The anchor
That leaves three central midfield positions, including the single pivot. The single pivot will act as a midfield anchor, and as far as players who can effectively play that position Guardiola is most likely to opt for Javi Martinez or Bastian Schweinsteiger. Despite the fact that Philipp Lahm has been fantastic in the defensive midfield role, his form hasn’t been worth holding out someone at either Schweinsteiger or Martinez’s level. It also doesn’t make sense to keep the best right-back in the world out of the right-back position, especially as Bayern moves forward in the Champions League.
The most likely candidate for the role is Javi Martinez, simply because he is of a similar mold of a player who played a similar role at Barcelona, Sergio Busquets. Both players provide a defensive cover and a hard tackling ability while being able to effectively connect the defensive to the attack. This isn’t to say Martinez is at the level of Busquets, but the similarity in their play is undeniable.
So where does this leave Schweinsteiger? To put it bluntly, leaving Schweinsteiger out of the starting lineup when fully fit should be punishable by public flogging. Schweinsteiger has the special ability to make a strong Bayern almost unbeatable. The best place for Schweinsteiger is in a central midfield position above the single pivot. This can give Schweinsteiger the freedom to move forward and join the attack or drop back and defend as necessary, shifting the formation from a 4-1-4-1 to a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 just by having him on the pitch.
That leaves on more central midfield position with players like Kroos, Thiago, Götze, and Müller all fighting for it, and it’s an incredibly difficult call. All players bring a different attribute to the table.
Toni Kroos brings sublime passing and an ability to control the game from either a central midfield or attacking midfielder position. Out of all the remaining midfielders, Kroos is the best passer and the best decision maker. He also provides a defensive aspect and superior tackling.
Mario Götze, the big summer signing (well, one of them at least) is a classic #10 with insane technical ability, fantastic passing technique, and recently good shooting. He’s probably the most well rounded attacker out of all the midfielders for this position and is far more likely to venture forward just behind the striker to create chances and score goals. Pretty goals, too.
Thiago Alcantara is a bit closer to Toni Kroos in the sense that he can drop back and play the central role and move up and play the attacking role as well. Thiago gives away the ball more than Toni Kroos does and may not make as many good decisions, but he’s also a better dribbler and when he’s on his game, he breaks records, like when he had 185 touches and 157 passes in the 5-0 drubbing of Frankfurt.
Thomas Müller is hard to explain, but suffice it to say that he adds that extra touch of chaos that Bayern sometimes need. His nickname “Raumdeuter” which means “interpreter of space” pretty much sums up his game. Nobody quite uses space like him, whether it’s creating a chance or scoring the most awkward hat tricks in the history of hat tricks. Regardless, Müller brings big game play that cannot be ignored.
So who gets the spot?
In my opinion, when everyone is fully fit the best option is Mario Götze, purely for tactical reasons. With Schweinsteiger and Martinez able to act as central midfielders, Bayern would be better off using Götze in that final spot if only for his ability to move behind the striker and create chances for Robben, Ribéry, or Mandzukic.
Götze also offers a bit more tactical flexibility should Guardiola decide to revert his midfield into a 4-3-3 or a 4-2-3-1. If he goes with the former, Götze can play a similar role to Andres Iniesta, floating behind the striker when he wants to or tracking back a little deeper depending on the situation. If Guardiola goes with the latter, then Götze can drop back into the #1o spot right behind Mandzukic and create chances or score goals. With six goals and four assists in just eleven Bundesliga games and three goals and one assist in the Champions League, it’s hard to argue with the Bavarian wunderkind’s form either.
It’s all about form
At the moment, it’s still impossible to say who will take the final spot. For now, with Javi Martinez and Bastian Schweinsteiger not fully ready to start games, it’s not an issue. But once they are ready to start games the rest of the midfielders will have to fight for that last spot and form will dictate who gets it.
Thankfully for Bayern, many of these players possess the ability to play various positions. Mario Götze can play either wing and the center forward position, and Thomas Müller has proven effective on the right wing and can play center forward if needed. Their dynamic styles of play will be helpful in the pursuit of playing time.
At the end of the day, form will dicate who plays in the midfield for Die Roten.